A New Rivalry

North Melbourne Football Club has been robbed of its traditional rivalries in recent years. But an AFL Gold Coast team presents a unique opportunity for NMFC to capitalise on a very real rivalry.

While rarely acknowledged in the media, North Melbourne has some fascinating traditional rivalries. The Hawthorn-North Melbourne rivalry, founded on the teams’ three Grand Finals in the 70s, has gained momentum in recent years with the clubs engaging in some controversial player trades. The most recent, the Hawk’s sniping of Josh Gibson, should make for an interesting grudge match in Round 5. But as is the AFL’s way, they have ignored the possibility of fixturing a mini-blockbuster, scheduling a twilight match in Tasmania!?!

But it is Essendon who North fans hold the most spite for, a rivalry that is arguably the most enduring in the game. It dates back to the 1890s, when Essendon actively fought against North Melbourne’s inclusion in the newly formed Victorian Football League. This was further inflamed in 1921 when North Melbourne agreed to amalgamate with Essendon in order to enter the VFL via a back door. After taking the cream of North Melbourne’s ‘invincible’ VFA team (including Syd Barker), Essendon decided to scuttle the deal, leaving North Melbourne with neither a VFL birth, nor a full team! Somehow, North managed to re-establish itself and successfully entered the VFL in its own right in 1925, but the team was a shadow of what it might have been.

By 1950, the fledgling North Melbourne club finally managed to build a premiership contending team and made its first Grand Final – against its old adversaries, Essendon. Down by 20 points at the final change, reports suggest that North threw everything at Essendon, including plenty of roundhouses, but ultimately went down by 38 points.

The rivalry gained a new energy in the mid-90s, with the two clubs becoming the dominant forces of the competition. Unfortunately, the salivating prospect of a Grand Final match never eventuated, but the teams’ encounters were no less enthralling, none more so than the Round 16 clash of 2001. Down by 69 points during the second quarter, Essendon dug deep and eventually clawed their way back to claim a famous 12-point victory ­­– dubbed the greatest comeback of all time. Notably, North Melbourne won the next six encounters, and the clashes continue to hold a sense of history about them.

And yet the AFL has only scheduled one match a season between the clubs since that memorable game in 2001. It seems AFL-endorsed rivalries only exist between powerhouse clubs, leaving North Melbourne out in the cold.

While NMFC should continue to press the AFL on the Essendon rivalry, it’s also time for some trademark North Melbourne innovation. I think it’s time to embrace a new rival: the Gold Coast. And unlike some of the fabricated rivalries of recent years (since when were Sydney and Brisbane rivals?), there’s no question that there will be feeling between the two clubs.

And there’s also no question that it’s in the AFL’s interests. With concerns over the size of crowds the GC will attract in Melbourne, a properly supported GC vs NM match could draw more fans than people might think. If scheduled during a marquee timeslot (a Friday night or a standalone match during the split round) and given some well-targeted promotion, 45,000 is achievable. People forget that it was only a few years ago that a similar crowd saw North play its first grudge match against Wayne Carey’s Adelaide.

To the disdain of the traditionalists, theatre is now seen as an important commodity in the AFL. Like it or not, it’s here to stay. And while North continue to receive no marquee fixtures despite repeated attempts (Good Friday, a WA home game), it’s time a bold new plan was put to the AFL. Forging a new rivalry with the AFL’s love-child seems about as good an opportunity as ever.

Make it happen, Eug.



Filed under Off Field

6 responses to “A New Rivalry

  1. You say that the AFL manufactures rivalries with Brisbane vs Sydney, but you’re also proposing a manufactured rivalry between North Melbourne and Gold Coast.

    Rivalries are built either on geographic proximity (like North Melbourne vs Essendon) or a history of important clashes (North Melbourne vs Hawthorn). You have to remember that it wasn’t that long ago that North Melbourne vs Sydney was considered a rivalry due to us playing games up there and a deterioration in the relationship between the two clubs. But now, North vs Sydney is just another game.

    In the end, I don’t think there’s any particular hostility towards the Gold Coast by North fans. The anger was directed more at the AFL and the then North administration than them. As it stands, we’re happy to have our club based in Melbourne, and they get to build their own club.

    • I don’t think it would be manufactured. I think many GC people were pissed at North for rejecting the offer. And while I agree that most North fans don’t really hold a grudge against the GC, they would take a lot of joy beating a club that threatened their club’s existence.

  2. I don’t think it would be a particularly “positive” rivalry if it’s based on what happened off the field. If you remember the North Melbourne vs Sydney rivalry, that was built up due to Greg Miller’s antics, and Richard Colless fighting back. North Melbourne vs Sydney games were just another game. But to see the “Boo A Roo” campaign and the sheer hostility towards us from the Sydney crowds in Sydney, I don’t think it added anything to the image of our club.

    • I don’t think your comparison is fair. The Sydney distaster was an attempt from NMFC to stomp on the Swan’s territory, and they were duly outraged. The GC situation is almost the exact opposite, where NMFC outright rejected the GC/AFL’s lures of riches.

      All I’m suggesting is NMFC capitalise on the small amount of support that still exists for the club on the GC, and the strong feelings many NMFC supporters retain regarding GC relocation talk. Put together properly and their encounters could easily become mini-blockbusters that would help NMFC’s crowds and exposure – even if only a little.

  3. Anton

    Gold Coast rivalry may happen for the first season, but no doubt that AFL will ensure that GC-Brisbane rivalry will be bigger for the rival rounds.

    Speaking of essenscum, perhaps NMFC should pressure on AFL to give NMFC the Good Friday Night Football game against either Essenscum or the Hawks. That will improve the ‘ratings’ of our rivalries.

  4. Pingback: Find three blogs that you find relevant to your personal interests. Create a link from your blog to these blogs. « Brooke Middleton's Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s